This volume contains the evolving reflections on the practice and discourse of transitional justice over the last decade or so, since the book transitional justice came out. Transitional justice takes this question to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the contemporary debate. What is novel about teitels approach is the attempt to provide an overarching approach to understanding issues that arise in and out of transitional justicethe book is filled with fresh ideas and interesting, provoking perspectivesessential reading for all those facing the complexities of transition in practice. At any such time of radical change, the question arises. Introduction this article proposes a genealogy of transitional justice. It speaks of several commonalities with regard to not only political manipulations of truth and memory, the abuses and misuses of transitional justice for scapegoating or political legitimacy, the role of liminality and transcendence, but also of the tradeoff. For a comprehensive analysis of transitional justice, see ruti g.
The genealogy contained in this chapter entails an intellectual history of the concept of transitional justice, a term the author coined in 1991 when observing the transitions of latin america and eastern europe. Ruty teitel, in one of the first extensive books on the subject, defines tj as a concept of justice. In the latest of transitions, transitional justice is no longer a byproduct or afterthought, but rather, the driver of political change. Teitel takes an interdisciplinary approach to examine key debates. Throughout the book, she examines the ability of different mechanisms aside from criminal punishment, namely the role of historical inquiries, reparations policies, administrative measures, and constitutional reform to promote justice. Examining the implementation of transitional justice measures in postauthoritarian indonesia, this book analyses the factors within the democratic transition that either. Traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional justice oup 2000. Transitional justice 1st edition kieran mcevoy louise. Summary of transitional justice beyond intractability. Transitional justice, it is argued, provides recognition of the rights of victims, promotes civic trust, and strengthens the d. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. First, it is organized chronologically, illustrating critical cycles divided into three phases of transitional justice.
Teitel description at the centurys end, societies all over the world are throwing off the yoke of authoritarian rule and beginning to build democracies. Offering a timely entry into transitional justice conversations on the world stage, this book offers a brilliantly critical analysis of the surprising genealogies of the practices and institutions that came to represent the transitional justice toolkit. In 1991, at the time of the soviet collapse and following the latin american transitions to democracy in the 1980s, teitel coined the term transitional justice to account for the selfconscious construction of a distinctive conception of justice associated with periods of radical political change on the heels of past oppressive rule luban 2006. The genealogy contained in this chapter entails an intellectual history of the concept of transitional. Searching for truth in the transitional justice movement by. Her pathbreaking book, transitional justice oxford university press, 2000, examines the 20th century transitions to democracy in many countries. Transitional justice, teitel argues, serves to construct a liberal political identity for the new state. The contemporary episodes in transitional justice discussed here, the trials of slobodan milogevit and saddam hussein, illustrate instances of phase iii transitional justice seeking of responses associated with postcold war global politics.
Second, the genealogy is organized largely along a schematic based on the law and politics of the developments associated with the three phases of transitional justice. Ruti g teitel among the most prominent and significant political and legal developments since the end of the cold war is the proliferation of mechanisms for addressing the complex challenges of transition from. She is recognized as an authority on transitional justice, not only by legal academics and practitioners, but also by those addressing these issues in the fields of political science, public policy, sociology, and philosophy. Born in argentina, professor teitel s interest in the topic grew out of the dilemmas confronting that society in the transition out of junta rule. Theorizing transitional justice by claudio corradetti, nir. Teitel provides a collection of her own essays that embody her evolving reflections on the practice and discourse of transitional justice since her book transitional justice published back in. Ruti teitel explores the recurring dilemma of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, yet contending that the law nevertheless plays a. The first academic program in israel devoted to transitional justice, it also supports, with other departments, the masters in human rights and transitional justice, multidisciplinary research, clinical work and community outreach. Postcommunist transitional justice edited by lavinia stan.
No longer a byproduct or afterthought, transitional justice is unquestionably the driver of political change. This book is the first to offer an indepth analysis of transitional justice as an unfinished agenda in indonesias democracy. Alison bisset, truth commissions and criminal courts. Friedgal transitional justice initiative the gal foundation.
Public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter. Ruti g teitel the publication of ruti teitel s transitional justice in 2000 was a landmark event for the study of the legal and political challenges of transition from oppression to democratic rule, coming on the. Ruti teitel has outlined a threestage transitional justice genealogy. Scholars and practitioners working in transitional justice are concerned with remedies of accountability and redress in the aftermath of conflict and state repression. Teitel traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional justice oup 2000 provides an interdisciplinary perspective deriving from many different national and regional contexts, and spanning the range of institutions and policy responses.
From perspectives both backward and forwardlooking, the conception of transitional justice was informed by the nature of and the degree of commitment to political repression. Ruti teitel, transitional justice genealogy, 16 harv. Global civil society and transitional justice springerlink. May 30, 2015 see recently jens iverson, transitional justice, jus post bellum and international criminal law. This volume succeeds in presenting a coherent and nuanced account of the post1989 experience of cee with dealing with the past. Transitional justice after the civil war request pdf. Browse the amazon editors picks for the best books of 2019, featuring our favorite reads. According to the international centre for transitional justice, a new. As instances of global transitional justice, these. Differentiating the usages, history and dynamics, 7 intl j transitional justice 20 4 arguing that a too broad definition of transitional justice, so as to include international criminal law and ius post bellum, decreases the potentiality of the three concepts. The author defines transitional justice as a framework to solve the fundamental problems of society, in political flux, through judicial and nonjudicial approaches.
Justice discourses in social and legal studies, christine bell, colm campbell and fionnuala ni aolain the rule of law and transitional justice in conflict and postconflict societies. Principle and pragmatism in strategies of international justice 28 international security 2004 5. This book proposes an idea of transitional justice mechanisms in order to portrait society problems under the democratic transition countries. Stiefel professor of comparative law at new york law school. An introduction to some issues in transitional justice. Stiefel professor of comparative law at new york law school and visiting professor at the london school of economics. Closing the books transitional justice in historical perspective. Ruti teitel, transitional justice genealogy, harvard human rights journal, 2003, vol. The highs, the lows and the expansion of the field cheryl lawther and luke moffett transitional justice is a field on an upward trajectory. The law and politics of comtemporary transitional justice by. As transitions to democracy have become more common, transitional justice has become a significant issue in many instances. Theorizing transitional justice ebook written by claudio corradetti, nir eisikovits.
Teitel introduction this article proposes a genealogy of transitional justice. Transitional justice consists of judicial and nonjudicial measures implemented in order to redress legacies of human rights abuses. Whether framed as a goal, perspective or a bundle of reformed institutions, transitional justice is one of the most contested multidisciplinary concepts within the discourse on postconflict societies. This is an insightful analysis of one of the most fundamental political science issues of our times how the emerging democracies in eastern europe and elsewhere should deal with the legal systems inherited from their authoritarian pasts. Ruti teitel explores the recurring dilemma of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, yet contending that the law nevertheless plays a profound role in periods of radical change. Transitional justice is enacted at a point of political transition from violence.
Such measures include criminal prosecutions, truth commissions, reparations programs, and various kinds of institutional reforms. Teitel, ruti, 2003, transitional justice genealogy, harvard human. Ruti teitel explores the ways in which a society should respond to evil rule. This article proposes a genealogy of transitional justice. An internationally recognized authority on international law, international human rights, transitional justice, and comparative constitutional law, ruti teitel is the ernst c. Traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional. Teitel summary written by eric brahm, conflict research consortium citation. Teitel provides a collection of her own essays that embody her evolving reflections on the practice and discourse of transitional justice since her book transitional justice published back in 2000. The law and politics of contemporary transitional justice. The gal foundation, a long time supporter of the hebrew university in jerusalem, established the friedgal transitional justice program at the law faculty in 2010. If transitional justice is made so elastic as implicitly to absorb international criminal law and jus post bellum, this lessens the potential value of transitional justice as a discrete, focused.
370 1101 197 267 920 521 536 1308 1230 837 37 54 1400 1573 1531 1232 1494 949 60 529 1273 303 185 484 1084 235 87 553 1184 488 157 769 381 1034 556 447 431 1008 1255 1207